Twinning Attitude!

Join Fran Pitre and friends for uplifting, supportive, healthy conversation and information on topics important to all moms (and all women) today!

Does addressing adults with respect promote good manners in children? July 6, 2010

Filed under: Let's talk about ... — twinningattitude @ 9:35 pm

This was a question recently posted on the website:

For me, I’ll answer the question in four words: Yes, ma’am, Miss Betty!

Of course, I will elaborate so as to support my answer. I know this is a LONG answer, but please hear (read) me out! I truly stand behind this position because of the experiences I had as a child in relation to the adults in my life, and I’m very thankful that I was raised that way.

As a child, I referred to my young cousins by their first names, but referred to my aunts and uncles as, for instance, “Aunt Joyce” and “Uncle Peter”. To this day, I still refer to them in this way. Part of the reason is out of force of habit, but more so because they are my elders. They’ve lived longer, are full of wisdom from life’s experiences, and this status warrants and deserves respect. I believe that my elders sense my respect for them and appreciate it, as well. Because my young cousins were my peers, I didn’t feel the same level of respect for them or for their opinions as I did for their parents. The same courtesy applied to the adult friends of my parents. I didn’t address them by their first names, as I did their children. If I’d done so, I’d have been in big trouble! By the way, I called my parents “Mom and Dad”, not “Steven and Claire”.

When we lived in New York, my brothers and I referred to our parents’ friends and other adults as “Mr. Smith” and “Mrs. Jones”. When we moved to Louisiana, the tradition in the south was (and still is) to refer to our adult family friends as “Miss Carolyn” and “Mr. John”. The reason again … respect for their position as our elders.

As new generations emerge and trends change, should it be expected that all traditions that were begun by our parents and grandparent change because new trends appear? Yes, in some cases, because of progress and growth of technology and new means of social interaction. But, some traditions must not lax, and for good reason. Addressing the generations that have come before us by showing them the respect that they deserve not only instills in children that elders should be revered and respected, but it instills good etiquette and manners that all adults appreciate from children who behave this way. Isn’t it apparent when children speak with respect and manners to elders, it displays a sense of intelligence? Isn’t it also true that when a child exhibits these respectful manners, it reflects as positive upbringing by his or her parents? The adult being addressed respectfully appreciates this courtesy. I know that as an adult, the occasions where I’d been addressed by a child by my first name, just didn’t sit right with me. I felt as though that child “should be taught some manners”, and I silently blamed the parents for the lack of proper parenting. To be honest, I felt a bit insulted. Do we want our children to unknowingly insult or “diss” the adults they would speak to?

Lastly, and most importantly, if we teach our children that it’s just fine to consider adults equals that can be placed on their same level … this may translate to the children that they really don’t have any reason to respect for their elders’ opinions, experiences, wisdom, advice, or any of the infinite benefits they could receive from the wisdom of the generations that came before them. If children don’t demonstrate respect and honor to adults by simply the way they address them, then why should children place any value on authority at all?

To teach our children respect for adults by instilling the manners of properly addressing adults, we give our children a reason to listen, to take their advice, to place value on what they teach them, and ultimately allows these children to learn. The appreciation felt by the adults being addressed properly, in turn, allows our children to be viewed as “being properly raised by their parents”. Our children will go on to repeatedly display these manners and receive mutual respect as they grow into adulthood themselves.

Please give us YOUR feedback!


9 Responses to “Does addressing adults with respect promote good manners in children?”

  1. Jennifer Sharp Says:

    My girls are “required” to address adults at Miss Betty and Mr. John. My parents are from the North so when I was a child, we addressed adults by Mr. Smith and Mrs. Jones. But now that we live in the South, it seems to be the norm to use first names with Miss or Mr. And I like that! It teaches children that we are to respect our elders and I don’t think it is ever too early to start that lesson.

  2. Trish Says:

    I was raised to address my elders with some kind of title, and my kids are being raised to do so as well. The kids’ friends generally address me with Miss or Mrs, and the ones that don’t I find myself just not trusting them as much as I would the others who do.

  3. Scott Circe Says:

    Definitely. I agree wholeheartedly with this article. I always cringe hearing a child or a teen for that matter being so bold to call adult simply by their first names.

  4. Thanks for the supportive comments! I, too, “cringe” when I hear children address adults by their first name. There is a children’s program on PBS where the pre-school children address their teacher by her first name (sometimes with the word “teacher” in front of it, but mostly just by the first name) … and I’m reminded that there really is a movement out there wanting to break down the respect that children have for authority, and to deliberately undermine it. I also feel that, like you, MOST parents (and most adults for that matter) will continue to enforce that children learn to respect and show that respect to adult family members and those authorities in their lives.

    Thanks again for your posts!!!

  5. Kristi Says:

    I will probably be in the minority here, but I don’t think it is a big deal to refer to adults by their first name. Aunt and Uncle are one thing, but I prefer to just be called Kristi, and it kind of bothers me when people have their kids call me Miss Kristi.

    • Hi Kristi … thanks for your input!
      I can see where you’re maybe coming from. Perhaps when you’re in your 20s or 30s, being addressed by younger people by being called “Miss —–” or even “Mrs. —–“, for instance, can make a person feel, or feel that they’re being regarded as, older than they actually are.

      I still feel that being regarded with respect, even when an 8-yr-old summer camper addresses a 19-yr-old camp counselor by calling him “Mr. Billy or Miss Lexie” reinforces that “authority and responsibility” lies with the counselor, and the camper should always remember that.

  6. Karen Quaiel Says:

    I was raised in the South and follow the southern rules regarding this topic. However, I married a man from MA and they don’t like the “proper” titles. It takes me a long time to adjust my thinking when I visit them. It feels disrespectful. Harder than that, is my husbands “northern” raising clashing with mine when he visits my family…yikes! Just recently, here in the South, a 20y/o friend of the family, called me by my first name…..didn’t like it…my kids won’t be raised to do it. My vote, keep the titles–to show respect (PS My grandparents used to call their friends title with last “Mrs Pitre”—we’ve relaxed our tradition, hahaha)

    • Hi Karen …
      Thanks so much for your reply!!!
      It’s encouraging to hear so many votes for “let’s keep the respectful titles” …
      I totally agree that “manners and respect simply never go out of style”!!!
      GREAT discussion, bloggers!!!
      ~ fran

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s